UPDATE: Anti-Abortion Protesters Hold Signs Outside Perry Hall High
Two protesters gathered outside the school between 7 a.m. and 8 a.m. Friday.
UPDATE (Oct. 5, 3:29 p.m.)—Two anti-abortion protesters demonstrated outside Perry Hall High School on Friday morning, assistant principal Stephen Arnold confirmed.
Between 7 a.m. and 8 a.m., standing on a public sidewalk near the school's entrance, they held signs showing aborted fetuses, according to Arnold.
"I think the protesters are there to get a reaction—so they're going to show pictures to get a reaction," he said.
They interacted with some students and community members, but no incidents were reported. The school's on-duty school resource officers verified that the protesters had a permit to demonstrate. They were not, however, required to warn the school in advance of their demonstration, according to Arnold.
He said they appeared to be part of the same group that demonstrated outside the school in February.
County Councilman David Marks said he had several concerns related to the demonstration.
"I am personally pro-life and I certainly support freedom of speech, but I wonder why this group selects schools and I worry about the safety of motorists distracted by these protesters," Marks said.
"Also, quite candidly, we in Perry Hall have had enough reminders lately of the importance of human life," he added.
Dennis M. Robinson, Jr., president of the Perry Hall Improvement Association, also released a personal statement on Friday.
"I am not weighing in on the issue of abortion. To be clear, I fully support and value the right of free speech we enjoy as Americans. The same right of free speech that permits protesters to display graphic images to high school students also permits me to say that I think their conduct is grossly distasteful to say the least," Robinson stated. "If they want to engage in that activity, I think they should go elsewhere. Let our high school students, who have been through enough this year, focus on learning."
Do you think this type of demonstration is appropriate outside of a school? Tell us in the comments.
PerryHallCrafter
2:01 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
I mean seriously, holding up signs of bloody and aborted fetuses? I realize that we have the right to free speech in this country, but if they were protesting being against pornography, would they be able to hold up sign of people engaged in intimate positions as part of their free speech? It's dirty, low shock tactics like that horrible group that uses military and high profile funerals to harass gay individuals. While personally I am pro-life, I do not have the right to tell others who are not a part of my faith or beliefs what to do with their own bodies. No one does. Showing a picture isn't going to change anyone's mind, it's going to create a lack of respect for those sending their "message", which, once you show something like that, is something no one wants to hear. Did anyone pull over and ask, "Hi, I see the bloody fetus there...tell me more, please!"
Bill Howard
3:37 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
During the Viet Nam war many horrible images were shown to the people and the government had to respect it. It's a shame that such images were not available at the beginning of the Holocaust. Maybe millions would have been saved.
If these murdered babies are NOT humans as the opposition claims than the pictures should be no more offensive than watching crabs and squid being cleaned. If you see the humanity in the person and the inhumanity in what happened, than you will feel differently.
May God use the martyred children of abortion to change the hearts of those who support their death.
John Doe
3:49 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
"support their death"?
John Doe
2:19 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
Why stop there? Try Gymboree next. What about Chick-fil-A? These losers need to be photographed and put on the Patch. I am more worried about the nightmares kids have from this. Losers.
Kate hardiek
8:24 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
trust me i have the picture he shoved in my face carved in the back of my head its horrible i hope he feels satisfied
patricia smith
2:36 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
to perryhallparent, john doe, and whoever else cares to hear/see the truth, as a former counselor in a pro-life crisis pregnancy center dealing with a population who make appointments not only for free pregnancy tests, free resources, free maternity/ baby clothes, formula, etc., but also help with post abortion stress/regrets, i can assure you that we are not losers . . .the aborted innocents (babies) are the losers, and the nightmarish facts are true; ask anyone who's gone through the procedure; you can ask them years from now because the pain and regret follow you . . . and to think that some endure multiple abortions, which can lead to infertility, suicidal ideation . . .just a thought . . .
PerryHallCrafter
2:41 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
You know what patricia smith? I know the truth. I am pro-life (for myself, I don't have the right to expect others to be; that's their business if they believe a certain way), have several children and experienced the loss of two children by miscarriage. However, you actually spoke in your message here and expressed your feelings. More people would actually respect you for this type of rhetoric and be open to discussion than exposing toddlers and children to pictures of bloody fetuses. I experienced quite a bit of pain, regret, grief and depression after the loss of my babies through miscarriage, so, just a thought. Try actually interacting with people instead of offending them for a change. People who hold up those signs are in the same, exact category as the Westboro Church protestors.
John Doe
3:16 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
I shouldn't have called them a name like 'losers'. Name calling is wrong. I will now call them "nightmare producers to young children", "selfish individuals who could have helped out at a homeless shelter that morning between 7 & 8 AM", "able-bodied citizens causing extended grief through pictures to those who have lost a child not by choice."
Mike Lurz
2:34 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
These people failed to take into account the middle school and elementary students passing through the area on their way to school...I fully support their right to free expression and their right to get the message out, can that NOT be done without the gore being shown to our young children, and hasnt PHHS been through enough in the past few months?
patricia smith
3:01 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
perryhallparent, john doe, etc - i commented I DO NOT AGREE WITH, NOR DO I CONDONE westboro church's methods/ tactics . . . that's why i (thought) i carefully worded my comment . . . and i'm aware of several miscarriages and 1 stillbirth in my immediate family . . . and yes, i feel much pain for each . . .(i'm a grandmom)
PerryHallCrafter
3:27 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
Well, if you don't condone their tactics, let's compare. Abortion protest outside Perry Hall High School: holding signs up showing shocking photos and statements...check; using a high profile establishment and high traffic area to garner interest in your (sickening) giant photos of bloodied fetuses (which we do not know as a fact are pictures of aborted fetuses)...check; justifying said actions and even going so far as to say that you don't condone the Westboro Church's tactics, although you do the same...check. Give me a break. No one agrees with you. If you feel the pain and you are a grandmom...shame on you. Try educating people with love and kindness, not blood and gore. I'm glad you aren't around my children.
Jeanne
11:55 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
Patricia Smith you claim to feel much pain for each of the severl miscarriages and 1 stillbirth in your family yet you are willing to carry these signs and defend these people. I had 3 miscarriages, the last one my daughter was the hardest on me and when I saw one of those signs all I could think about is was that what my daughter looked like? Was that what the other miscarriages looked like. She would have been 20 this June and the days get a lot easier but those pictures to "educate" people are a knife in my heart and I am sure I am not the only one that feels that way. If you feel much pain for the babies & their parents how can you do this? My husband keeps me away from areas these people are because he wants to save me the pain, what about people that can't avoid the areas these people are, they shouldn't feel the pain either.
I'm sorry your family has suffered so much, the babies are all in heaven with relatives that watch over us. When my father died one of the only things that gave me piece of mind is he was in heaven spending time with his grandaughter.
Honeygo Hal
4:41 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
Just guessing that they might have thought demonstrating in front of the high school would get them the most exposure with all that has happened there.
patricia smith
1:15 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
i'm not understanding why i'm feeling attacked . . . as i've commented more than once, I DON'T AGREE, NOR HAVE I EVER . . . . I'VE NEVER, nor would i EVER demonstrate ANYWHERE like the westboro church has done . . . there's some kind of misunderstanding here . . seems to me my comments are falling on deaf ears . . . oh, well . . .
John Doe
1:31 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
...and there lies the problem...
Mike Lurz
4:43 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
Playing off the tragedy of others...classy
Laura
5:07 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
I truly hate these signs! I see them everywhere! I'm suppose to explain to my 5 year old and my 7 year old what these pictures are! This is disgusting. Shame on them for protesting with THOSE pictures around schools where the Elementary and Middle schools are. And for crap sake, stay away from the High School too! These pictures are disturbing to an adult. I have no respect for these protesters. They are just slime for not caring about the children that have to see these signs. How ironic that you are against abortion because you care so much about life, but you don't give a damn about the kids that have to see these disgusting pictures. I'm going to start protesting against dumb ass people who only care about themselves!
Kate hardiek
8:18 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
i personally went up there to say something to them this morning because what they are doing is sooo wrong i understand there is a right to protest but this is so un needed as i told the man today the he was in the wrong because there are 13 an 14 year old children that dont need to see these NOR DO I its for the parent and there child and families to descide what they do with a pregnancy not some random man that shoved his picture right in my face these people have no heart and they think there in the right but there not
Arlow
11:16 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
I'd have taken it and shoved it someplace else on him.
Bill Howard
3:41 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
Actually Kate there are 13 and 14 year old children having abortions with no idea what is happening other than those who tell them they need one. At least now they will start to have some idea.
Do Little
9:56 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
One plural word..morons!
Arlow
11:16 pm on Friday, October 5, 2012
73% of Americans are in favor of some form of abortion rights. Why do we let these idiots act like they're in the majority?
HLV
11:03 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Please site your source, dear Arlow.
P.S. The majority is the 50 million aborted babies.
Source: According to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), since 1973, roughly 50 million legal induced abortions have been performed in the United States.[37] World wide, there have been over 1,260,000,000 abortions performed.
Tim
1:41 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
50 million babies. Guess how many of those would grow up into having miserable lives, with parents who weren't married/didn't love each other, didn't have jobs or the willingness to properly take care of them.
We'd have that many more people being wards of the government.
The real problem is the teen and young adult sex. Another problem is having a system that essentially pays the poor to breed. I understand why it happens, either option is messed up (government supporting them, or not doing so and letting them die)
Education is key, with abstinence being ideal but also accepting that birth control options need to be available for teens and young adults to compromise on their desires yet still be responsible.
One way or the other, religious zealots can't just bury their head in the sand and ignore reality. We have millions of children of reproducing age now who are quite frankly poorly parented. It is what it is. Bitching isn't going to fix anything.
Real solutions are required, not sermons from hypocrites in their day to day life.
JD1
9:45 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Well said Tim - too much rhetoric on both sides with no real solutions.
Gods girl
12:45 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
?
Gods girl
1:16 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
It amazes me that everyday, children are dieing horrible deaths, but people can post here that, the people who are trying to get the message out our the bad ones. Our world is crazy and flipped. In School 6th graders learn all about the Myans and there bloody sacrifices including child sacrifices, they learn about people eating people, the Holocaust. Who is complaining about that? When they are watching movies on this at school? The reason that people are out there like this is because, everyone trys to pretend it doesn't happen, but it does. It is horrible and horrific and needs to stop that is why they are out their to get the truth out. Maybe the problem is if our kids see this they are smart enough to realize it is murder, and you will have to explain to them why you think it is ok. I guarentee you if show one of these pictures to a child and ask them what they think, with out anyone filling their heads with bias thoughts, they will wonder why someone would kill that child. It amazes me the people there fighting for the right to kill their child and hating the people who care enough to put up with the abuse to tell the truth. Please take time read the stories of women whose lives were devestated by abortion. Read about what really happens, how many of your have seen an abortion, or know how they do them? Have you really taken the time to know the truth?
patricia smith
3:05 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
thank you, Gods girl . . .
Bill Howard
3:55 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
Gods girl you are so right. People this year are putting a lot of confidence in the Mayan death calender and they do study human sacrifice in the schools. However, because the Government commands it, somehow that is OK. The schools are full of depressing images and literature but those are Government approved and supported by the Secular Socialist teachers' unions. The public schools teach that if the Government says something it is true and whatever people of God say are myths. Our kids are given at least 13 years of such indoctrination. Our job is to break the chain of this mis-education.
"Rescue those who are unjustly sentenced to death; don't stand back and let them die." Proverbs 24:11
Dan W
8:33 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Hey Gods Girl,
Most if not all of the people outraged at these extremest would defend their right to protest, where it crosses the line is when they are issued a permit to be inside a school zone and show graphic and disturbing images to young children. If these pictures were in a R rated movie anyone under 17 would not be allowed to view it without a parent so why does Kurt Linneman of Kingsville (yes that's the ring leaders name) and his followers get to decide when its ok to terrify our young children with a horrific encounter on a street corner. If he wants to protest fine but if u want to be an extremest then go stand outside the abortion clinic and show ur pictures. Don't compare what this nut is doing to learning about sensitive issues in a structured environment. I urge every parent outraged to contact councilman David Marks and demand that this group be restricted from showing R rated images in a public form. I was told by Baltimore County's permit office that Col. Evans of the Baltimore County Police Department is the person responsible for issuing the permit. He needs to understand the danger our children were put in Friday as hundreds of drivers were distracted in front of the school where 2000 kids enter in a 40 minute time frame. Col. Evans, protect the public, don't issue a permit inside OUR school zone and endanger OUR children's lives!
Mike Lurz
8:38 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
to Gods Girl (?) is there not a better way to get out your "message" than to traumatize my kids?...you have a right to your beliefs, and my kids have a right to theirs...nowhere in that is your right to force said beliefs on my kids
HLV
10:57 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Hi Mike --- I agree with you, "you have a right to your beliefs, and my kids have a right to theirs...nowhere in that is your right to force said beliefs on my kids."
How do you feel about celebrating LGBT Day in Baltimore County schools?
Mike Lurz
11:06 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
I dont have a problem with it..and if you do you can hide from it if you choose...but I can assure you that porn wont be used to get the point of treating ALL people with respect across
Rita Weber
9:23 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
I think the Licensing and Permit Department should had a rule/law that no permits for this type of protesting will be allowed within 5 miles around ANY and ALL schools. I know 5 miles is extreme but it would keep them away from our schools.
I am not against any organization for their beliefs, but we do not need it shoved down our throats either. They do not need the graphic pictures to get their points across. I am sure they would have gotten more discussion or the same reaction with just words. I mean most people are very curious and concerned of anyone or group in the area of PHHS lately.
Bill Howard
3:59 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
So we should have a new board of Censorship at the Permits Department?
I don't think so.
HLV
10:55 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
I agree, these photos are horrible!
Why can't they use photos of babies HAPPY to be aborted?
Mike Lurz
11:03 am on Saturday, October 6, 2012
could you possibly miss the point any more?
Tim
1:42 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Religious folks tend to lack critical thinking, considering religion and faith require the absence of such attributes.
Jeanne
2:40 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Everyone has a right to their point of view and to discuss it with people willing and wanting to listen and hear their point of view. NO ONE has the right to shove thier opinion down other people's throats. These people are just like that religous group that protest funnerals. When will they realize that doing extreme things like this will only push woman into not asking questions, not thinking about her choices, etc.... Parents please be open with your children and let them know you are there if they need you, this makes things easier for the parents and their children. Hopefully no more permits will be issued to this group due to thier extreme nature.
Mike Lurz
10:30 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
totally agree
JD1
9:52 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Lousy way to get a point across - I wonder if images like these are used in the BCPS high school health curriculum. If not, they should be. If high school kids are old enough to have sex, they can view the ugly truth that may be the result of irresponsible behavior. Definitely a teaching tool, but not appropriate for roadside signage. Free speech can get ugly....
Mike Lurz
10:29 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
WOW, you take a lot of liberties with other people's kids...the decision of whether they are old enough to see these images is not yours to make. Besides, it wasnt just the high school kids that saw those images, it was the elementary and midle school kids..You are welcome to your views, and to express them, but NOT to decide ANYTHING for my kids...
John Doe
1:34 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
"definitely a teaching tool?" - so, when they discuss the digestive system, they should put a big pile of sh-t on the table for all to see?
patricia smith
3:17 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
JD1 - i agree
PerryHallCrafter
4:51 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
John Doe, your digestive system comment had me truly LOL for quite a bit of time. It even morphed here into a Crohn's disease poster idea for awareness (I have it, so I try to cope with humor) and how we could put your idea to use. I mean hey, when it all comes down to it "in the end" right? These protesters are out of their minds and no one agrees with them and they are doing a disservice. I have children old enough to know about these things and they say all it does it make people more apt to "buck the system" and do what they want to do. Gentle and caring education is the way to go with something like this and these protesters are totally missing the way to get their information through to people. Shock and Awe doesn't work anywhere.
JD1
10:45 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Unfortunately Mike - it's already decided for you. If you notice, I suggested viewing images in a classroom and not on the street. BCPS already includes lots of liberal slants on human sexuality in its high school health curriculum. Seems to me that leaving this side of the story out of the curriculum is only telling a portion of the story. If the goal of the curriculum is to help kids make responsible choices regarding health, than the truth and ugliness of abortion should be included.
patricia smith
3:20 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
how true - the truth & ugliness should be included . . .
Mike Lurz
10:53 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
God forbid our children should learn about their bodies and how they work it's called science and it is neither liberal or the work of the devil...I hope that I never need to make this choice but given it, i would rather my kids see a porno than mutilation of human bodies..Liberal slants what pray tell are they? As Americans we have the option NOT to choose a public education...sounds like you have an axe to grind ...Im telling you to keep it away from my kids and I am far from alone in this.
Mike Lurz
10:54 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
Oh, and it is my job as a parent to teach some things..it's not ALL the schools job. If you want your kids to know that side, thats YOUR chose, teach them. But you WILL NOT make that choice for my kids or me.
JD1
11:01 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
No axe - but you may want to inform yourself and take a look at the curriculum. Keep your CAPS in check - sounds like you have the axe and not me. Just telling it like it is....
John Doe
2:20 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
JD1 - you tell Mike Lurz to "Keep your CAPS in check", but say "Free speech can get ugly" right before in another post. That is his freedom of speech. GET YOUR STORY STRAIGHT - JUST TELLING IT LIKE IT IS...
Mike Lurz
11:05 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
by "inform myself" you mean comply with your beliefs...no thanks, I have my own
JD1
11:10 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
No - you don't have to agree with me - but you should read the BCPS curriculum so you are aware of its content to see what has been included and omitted - that is the entire point of my original post. What's even more interesting, is that the controversial course content is often delivered by gym teachers who are hardly qualified to be discussing human sexuality.
Tim
11:55 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
JD: I definitely hear what you are saying.
Mike, you as a parent sound like you're actually doing your job. I wish our society had more of you.
I just wonder if schools have, over time, been almost forced into this position of teaching sex ed.
patricia smith
3:21 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
so true!
Other Tim
11:55 am on Sunday, October 7, 2012
Just a quick note to people who object to the use of CAPS: typing comments on Patch does not allow the use of underlining, italics or bold letters. The only way to emphasize certain words or statements is to use CAPS.
patricia smith
3:23 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
YUUUP!
John Doe
3:27 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
Patricia Smith - at least you are consistent with your "thoughts". Now, get some of your 'group' together and get on down to the closest Chuck E. Cheese and educate those kids!!!
patricia smith
1:30 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
for the very last time (wondering now if they can read, I'M NOT IN A GROUP - I WOULD NEVER EVER STOOP TO SUCH TACTICS AS WESTBORO IS PARTICIPATING IN . . . oh, well . . . i'm exhausted trying to defend crisis pregnancy centers and myself . . .
John Doe
3:33 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
Patricia Smith - I recommend you and your "followers" head down to Ravens stadium after a football game (preferably a loss to the Steelers) and stand outside the gates. See what kind of reaction you get there. PS - bring some Band-Aids. Your "group" doesn't have the guts to do this, although you don't mind showing the guts of babies for others to see.
Evets
6:57 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
I agree with John Doe, a loss to the Steelers is preferable...
Evets
7:04 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012
However, I disagree with the point expressed in the comment above. Citizens have the right to express an opinion (yes, even using [or especially using] methods we find repugnant). Citizens do not have the right to use violence to express an opinion or prevent others from legally expressing an opinion. Also, expressing most any opinion after a game at Ravens stadium (actually M & T Bank Stadium) after a loss, where a some proportion of fans are likely to be drunk, is likely to lead to violence.
John Doe
10:33 am on Monday, October 8, 2012
Evets - I agree with you - violence is never an answer. That proves my point. These 'disciples' of the unborn fetus specifically map out areas and times where there is less likely to be violence, such as a busy road where you can't stop during a rush hour, or a school during a time where the kids have to go in or they will be tardy. Now, if these "educators" want to really get their point across, then they should have a float at the Macy's Parade on Thanksgiving morning with a floating fetus right in front of Snow White to teach her a lesson. I would love to hear Al Roker comment on that!
Evets
11:02 am on Monday, October 8, 2012
Doubt that Macy's would allow that, and since they are a private entity and not the goverment, that is their right.
I think protesters have their event in palces wherre they will likely gets lots of publicity, as this article in the Patch demonstrates.
John Doe
1:01 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
The Macy's part was the joke of the paragraph.
Evets
1:57 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012
I figured...
ammieoakley
11:00 am on Tuesday, October 16, 2012
Westboro often protests outside of a main gate to Fort Bragg and there are assigned soldiers standing by to protect them from the passerby. No soldier wants that task, but they know they promised to uphold the ideals of the US. Recently Westboro protested at a friend's funeral and the amount of people, including the Patriot Guard quietly standing in formation around the church to block the family members from view of the Westboro folks was amazing.
I do not see how you can compare the two. The folks from Westboro are mocking and disrespecting a life given selflessly for our country. Do I think it is right to protest abortion with horrific pictures? No, not necessarily. However, I do think about the amount of girls that got abortions when I was a student at PHHS less than 10 years ago and can't help but wonder if they would have still made that choice today. In a world where people seem to teach their kids that people and relationships are disposable, no wonder the divorce rate and amount of abortions are so high. And not every kid is having sex. Some parents still instill some strong values and morals in their kids. It's not the school's job to teach our kids about birth control. It's ours. And why are the pictures so shocking and disgusting if abortion is a perfectly acceptable practice?