Parents: Do I Still Need a Baby Monitor?
Tell us the right age to stop using a baby monitor in a child's room.
Someone asked me recently when I stopped using the baby monitor with my kids. I nearly choked on her question. Why? Because this is a long standing debate between me and my husband. He think I need to finally get rid of the baby monitor.
My youngest is more than 2 years old, and I am ashamed to admit that I still have a monitor in his room.
Maybe it’s a sentimental feeling that I think he needs me during the night, or I'm afraid I won’t hear him if he cries. More likely, however, I’m just not ready for him not to be my baby anymore.
Despite the fact that I complain about the monitor constantly, I can’t make myself turn it off. Even with the volume and sensitivity on the lowest level, it’s a constant noise maker in my bedroom. It makes sounds all night long as it picks up my son moving around, snoring and even noise from the street.
To be quite honest, it keeps me awake and I can’t stand it. But on the rare occasion that my son cries out in because he needs me, I fear I won't hear him without the monitor.
Some experts feel that parents don't need a baby monitor once the child is sleeping through the night, around 6 months old. Some even believe that using a monitor may make a child, who should self-soothe back to sleep, more likely to wake up.
My son is a good sleeper, so it’s very unusual that I go into his room in the middle of the night. So, why can’t I turn the silly thing off? Maybe it's because he still sleeps in a crib and can’t just wander into to my room to wake me up if he’s sick or has had a bad dream. Perhaps this is why I feel compelled to keep the monitor turned on.
But maybe it's time to get rid of the monitor and allow myself a peaceful night's sleep. What do you think?
Please share your parenting advice to help Perry Hall parents—myself included—struggling to cut the cord on the baby monitor. How old was your baby when you removed it from their room? Tell us in the comments.
Mamato3pumpkins
11:41 am on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
Just turn it down so you don't hear every little sound. I don't understand being embarrassed? My daughter's room is quite far from my own and I still use it--she is 4.5 yrs old. I have been glad for it on occasions when she is sick especially. Then again, it doesn't "bother" me a bit.
Stacey Schantz
12:04 pm on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
I do have it set on the lowest level, but it clicks on and off all night long... I'm thinking there must be a 12-step program for weaning myself off of this! :)
Paul Amirault
5:36 pm on Thursday, April 19, 2012
No. Just one step program. Sledge hammer the daggum thing <[:-))
Did it ever do you any good?
Nessy
11:53 am on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
I would turn it off. Re-purpose it for monitoring your kids play area, so you can keep an ear on them, even when you can't keep an eye on them. Like when you are tackling the mountain of laundry. (or maybe I am the only one with a mountain of laundry.) You can always move it back in to the bedroom on nights when one of your children are sick, just like you would break out the humidifier for them.
Stacey Schantz
12:05 pm on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
This is a great idea, Nessy! I too suffer from a constant mountain of laundry, and my kids play in our basement a lot. Having it down there would be helpful!!!
Tim
11:55 am on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
I forget when we stopped using it, but Ell started sleeping out of crib around 2. I know we didn't use it then.
I am a very heavy sleeper, and a big concern for me was that I'd never hear my baby cry. Sure enough though, the nurture/parent mechanism allowed me to hear him cry if he cried long enough without my wife soothing him.
Honestly, Stacey, if you've been sleeping terribly all this time, you've likely got no risk of sleepig through any serious crying of his. Your deep sleeping is ruined long term as it is.
Stacey Schantz
12:07 pm on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
Tim, you crack me up!!!
Robyn Alvarez
12:28 pm on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
I knew there'd be a day when I'd unplug the monitor, but I haven't yet. For us, though, our girls are downstairs from us, and we really can't hear them if they cry out. I don't need it often in the middle of the night for our 2yo, but it's good to know when she finally falls asleep or wakes up in the morning. Our older daughter is 5, and she still needs occasional soothing from nightmares or the few times she falls out of bed. Without her monitor, who knows how long she'd be downstairs screaming before I heard her. I sleep like a rock. We also use the monitors as an alarm clock. I know we'll have to get rid of them one day because teenagers will want their privacy, but I don't foresee it happening anytime soon.
Stacey Schantz
7:24 pm on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
Robyn, I'm trying so hard to turn it off, as it keeps me awake hours a night. Last night I did turn it off but woke at 3am in a panic and turned it back on. Perhaps sometime soon, I'll feel comfortable enough. I understand it if they were on a different floor, but honestly, my 2yo is within 25 feet of my bed... I'm just neurotic.
Paul Amirault
1:06 pm on Thursday, April 12, 2012
The simple one step cure. Step on the daggum thing and break it. Just like a binky!
A38
12:53 pm on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
I'd just get a new monitor that isn't so static-y. We still use our for our almost 6yr old and 2 yr old. We live in a small house and I don't always hear them, nor do I want my 6 yr old screaming (thus waking his sister) b/c he thinks I can't hear him. Nothing wrong with doing what makes you comfortable and safe in the world of parenting.
Stacey Schantz
7:15 pm on Wednesday, April 11, 2012
I'd love a new monitor, but as my husband is 100% against it, since My sons room is immediately next door to ours, he will not let me buy a new one...
John c vincent
5:36 pm on Thursday, April 19, 2012
Of course it is nice.good mama knows best
Jon
9:28 am on Thursday, April 12, 2012
We turned ours off around when the kids hit 18mos. Since your son's room is next to yours, just leave the doors open. You'll hear him when there's an issue, but will now get some more sleep - and hopefully your husband will also!
Tracey
10:12 am on Thursday, April 12, 2012
put the monitor on Troy's side of the bed for a while. ;) No seriously, I would move it across the room, or into the bathroom or something so that you don't here all the small noises, but you would definitely hear crying out.
We used the monitor I believe through his 3rd year....we run a fan in our room for white noise, so hearing him without the monitor is a little more difficult. Granted, he started coming to our door knocking, and then the monitor became pointless. You will be there soon enough. I still used the monitor for our annual beach trip though, so that we can be out in the hot tub and hear if the munchkin wakes up in the big house. Super handy!
Tim
10:19 am on Thursday, April 12, 2012
I was going to say. Not long into his third year he was having zero difficulty waking up in the middle of the night and knocking on our door.
Felicia
10:31 am on Thursday, April 12, 2012
It would be hard to tell if I were dead or sleeping. I hear nothing. But, I had a great monitor - my husband would wake me to tell me to get up cause the baby was crying.